とあるレッスン中の問題で疑問があったので誰かご確認お願いします。
Layla You have taken one of his classes before, haven't you?
Emily Yes. I took one when I was an undergraduate, and I remember it was one of the most interesting science classes I've ever had
質問
Has Emily taken Dr. Brown's class before?
How did she like it?
フィリピン講師の答え。
She remember it was one of the most science class she had ever had.
先のお二方が答えられているように、「それは最高の科学の授業だった」"it was one of the most interesting science classes"と過去形なので、「彼女がかつて受けたクラスで」の部分は、その過去のとき以前に起きている必要があるので、"she had ever had"と過去完了が適当だと思います。
別件でもう一つ。
「フィリピン講師の答え」の"She remember it was one of the most science class she had ever had."で、疑問点がいくつか。
まず、文頭は"She remember"ではなく、"She remembered"と過去形か、または、"She remembers"と三単現の"s"が付いた現在形かのどちらかだったと思います。(または講師のミスタイプ?)
次に、"one of the most interesting science classes"と、"interesting"がないと変だという点。されに、classは"classes"と複数形のはず。(これらも、講師のミスタイプ?)
これらが、全部講師のミス?ミスタイプだったとすると・・・。
Layla You have taken one of his classes before, haven't you?
Emily Yes. I took one when I was an undergraduate, and I remember it was one of the most interesting science classes I've ever had
質問
Has Emily taken Dr. Brown's class before?
How did she like it?
フィリピン講師の答え。
She remember it was one of the most science class she had ever had.
この答えは何故she has ever hadでは無く過去完了形なのでしょうか?